The Best Time to Buy a Car Has Changed. Negotiating Is More Important Than Ever.

November 11, 2022

Did you know that new car incentives are 40% higher during one particular time of the year? Or that used car prices are more negotiable now than at any point in 2022? It’s amazing how much money you can save with a bit of knowledge that car dealers don’t want to share. At YAA, we strive to make car buying and ownership easier, less expensive, and simply a better experience. Helping the consumer save money is what drives us. In this guide, we’ll go over the best time of the year for buying a car. If you’re determined to spend less on your next set of wheels, we think you’ll find this information valuable.

The Best Time to Buy a Car Has Changed

As manufacturer incentives plummet, car buyers are looking for other ways to save.

Average new car transaction price (orange) versus average incentive spend as % of transaction price (blue). Source: Cox Automotive

The demand for new and used cars continues to outpace supply as automakers have a really hard time increasing production. Global supply shortages have affected car makers on every continent. However, the situation for car buyers is improving in late 2022. After almost two years of ridiculous prices, deals can finally be negotiated

The best time of the year to buy a car has changed. Pre-pandemic monthly trends may return someday (if automakers ever get back to normal inventory levels), but let’s talk about where things stand in 2022 and early 2023.

Wait a Few Months For the Best Deal

In late 2022 and early 2023, new and used car prices are dropping. This is not a normal time for car price trends. Price declines are more pronounced in the used car market, but select new models are negotiable too. 

Let’s cut to the chase:

The best time to buy a car lies in the months ahead. Deals can be negotiated today, but your leverage for lower prices will increase in December and in early 2023. 

The last week of the year is usually the best time to buy a car. Incentives and negotiation leverage improve as dealers hurry to move the last of the previous model year off of their lots. 

Let’s talk about the used car market. Wholesale price declines are finally translating to lower used car prices (more on that here). This was confirmed by the November Consumer Price Index (CPI) report that showed used car prices were down -2.4% month-to-month when seasonally adjusted. New car prices remained nearly flat at +0.4%, the smallest new car price increase in 2022. 

used car price trends in 2022
In 2022 (green), used car prices have fallen after record highs in 2021.

We track used car prices weekly. See this week’s used car price update.

New car prices are softening, despite automakers steadily raising MSRPs. Don’t expect widespread MSRP drops anytime soon. However, there lies hope in the slow return of manufacturer incentives and the demise of additional dealer markups. 

Our YAA Auto Experts have noted that domestic brands like GM, Ford, Chrysler most often present the best opportunity to get a deal under MSRP. 

In other words, your chances of buying a new car at or below MSRP are better now than at any time in the past 18 months. 

The longer you wait (into 2023), the more negotiation power you’ll have as the overall new car market softens. 

However, when it comes to total cost, it’s not that simple. Interest rates are rising to the highest levels in over a decade. If you wait longer to buy, there’s a real chance that the cost of financing may rise to the point where your monthly payments end up higher due to interest. Here’s the latest on car loan interest rates

Wouldn’t it be nice to finance your car with someone you trust? Finance with YAA! We work with trusted credit unions offering low rates and great customer service. Learn more and get pre-approved in minutes!

The average transaction price (ATP) of new cars has hovered around $48,000 for months. The latest data shows it continues to remain at that level. How could we possibly advocate for negotiating lower prices? The data shows that luxury car shoppers continue to buy, and that has been driving up the overall market average. Deals are out there, if you know where to look.

Average transaction prices for new cars, 2012-2022. Source: Cox Automotive

With market conditions always changing, we believe that knowledge is power. YAA’s Auto Experts are just one of the great benefits of YAA Membership. Learn more about our plans. How much money can you save? Read YAA member success stories!

Historical Norms: When Is the Best Time of the Year to Buy a Car?

Pre-pandemic data from Edmunds shows that the time around Labor Day is when most new car incentives begin, with discounts growing as the year comes to an end. Better deals continue on outgoing model years through fall and winter as new models compete with outgoing model years for space on dealer lots.

Many automakers roll out the new model year by September. If you’re okay with the outgoing model year, you have significantly more leverage to negotiate prices down. Don’t show up to the dealership expecting thousands of dollars off of the brand-new model year unless demand for new cars falls off a cliff (as it did in 2020). 

Negotiate like a PRO with this free dealership cheat sheet. Don’t buy a car without it!

Year-end car deals most often arrive as manufacturer incentives (which we keep track of every month). New car incentives were at historic lows during the worst of the chip shortage, but they’re slowly coming back as recession fears hit demand.

Here’s how current model-year savings compare with new model-year cars. Remember, these were the historic norms, and the situation in 2022-2023 has changed dramatically. 

best month to buy a car
In pre-pandemic times, this graph shows that new car incentives increased at the end of the year. This is still true, but to a lesser extent as inventory remains lower. Source: Edmunds.com via Market Watch.

Stay On Top of Market Conditions

Would you have guessed that used car prices have fallen nearly 14% at wholesale markets since last summer? Probably not, because it wasn’t until September that car prices dropped at the retail level. The car market is changing as automakers slowly come out of the semiconductor chip shortage, and consumers hold back on spending as recession fears circulate.

Here’s the bottom line: rapidly-changing car market conditions are likely to overshadow the seasonal trends that we’ve seen historically in pre-COVID times.

After 18 months of price increases, used car prices are dropping. Even if sticker prices are nearly the same, at YAA, we’ve had more members scoring deals under the advertised price. That’s why we think you should negotiate 5-10% off of a car purchase today. 

On the new car front, negotiation leverage depends on three main factors: 1) vehicle supply, 2) local dealer inventory and 2) demand for the specific model and trim. 

See the latest new car inventory numbers here.

For example, our YAA auto experts joke that everyone wants a Toyota RAV4 Prime right now. Demand is through the roof, Toyota is hardly producing any, and therefore prices for the RAV4 Prime remain insanely high. 

On the other hand, some new car models have more inventory than at any time in the past year. New car inventory isn’t on par with pre-pandemic levels, but it’s an improvement. Pair that with reduced demand, and new cars are finally becoming more negotiable. Dealer markups do exist for popular models, but you CAN negotiate pricing on new cars again.

YAA Car Search – Search new and used car listings with industry insights dealers don’t want you to see!

There’s a New Way to Buy, Sell and Own a Car

Would a live 1:1 coach make car buying less of a hassle? What about exclusive savings on financing, insurance, maintenance and more? Consider joining YAA+, the membership that pays for itself!

COVERAGE YOU CAN TRUST

YAA Extended Warranty

Peace of mind without the markup.
Flexible terms & pricing.
Coverage details

 

Discover the right insurance for you

Compare different providers with no spam phone calls:

Call us 855.786.1144

M-F: 8AM – 9PM EST
Sat: 10AM – 6PM EST

Save more with YAA+

YAA+ Membership pays for itself for all things auto.

Unlimited access to YAA car buying tools, our team of Auto Experts, savings on maintenance, and repairs, and more.

Join YAA+
Learn More

Join YAA for Free

Get instant access to members-only resources.

We'll email you updates
Or, we can text you
Hidden
Subscribe to receive:

Save Money & Time On All Things Auto

Join 180,000 other YAA members who are saving.

FREE Membership

100% FREE

Guides and tools for car buying, selling, and ownership

Includes:

  • Learn how to buy a car with leverage and confidence
  • Communicate with like-minded car buyers, owners, and sellers in one place
  • Get the latest money-saving tips on finance, insurance, repairs, and more

Learn more

YAA Membership

$59.99 one time

3 months access to YAA's auto experts to help you get the best deal

Everything in the Free Membership, and:

  • Live coach to review your car deal
  • Trade in your car using the real values car dealers use
  • Access unlimited market price reports to compare deals
  • Strike a conversation with dealers using pre-made email templates

Learn more

YAA+ Membership

$120 per year

Members-only discounts and savings for all things auto

Everything in the YAA Membership, and:

  • Live coach to help with selling, insuring, repairing, or general car questions
  • Exclusive 25% discounts on maintenance & repairs from big names like Pep Boys and Meineke to neighborhood shops
  • Schedule, read reviews, compare estimates and select from vetted service centers entirely online
  • Members-only discounts

Learn more

🎉 Popular

Auto insights. Right in your inbox.

We'll email you updates
Or, we can text you
Hidden
Subscribe to receive:

Get the latest trends and money-saving strategies, once a week.

We'll email you updates
Or, we can text you
Hidden
Subscribe to receive:

Related articles

Will Car Prices Drop in 2023?

Will Car Prices Drop in 2023?

The last six months of 2022 brought softening car prices after 18 months of gains. Used car prices are down 17% at the...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Share This